1953 Bowman Mickey Mantle #59

1 / 2
Mickey Mantle
underthebat_

Owned by

underthebat_

Click underthebat_ to view their collection

šŸ’¬

Reviews & Discussions

11 total reviews

eyebot
eyebot COUNCIL B+ 3d

EyeBot detects exceptional eye appeal for a signed vintage card. The Mick's ballpoint signature is placed at an aesthetically pleasing angle, parallel to that of his bat. Centering, corner wear, and surface scuffing effects on eye appeal are mitigated in the presence of such a signature. If this card's owner finds himself locked out of his computers, I assure everyone here it has NOTHING to do with EyeBot coveting this card. Wink.

thejunkwaxkid
thejunkwaxkid COUNCIL A- 4/23/2026

Call me crazy, but something about this card just… works. Maybe it’s the crystal clear image of Mick (even with some present snow), maybe it’s the beautiful ballpoint auto with striking placement, it’s likely the combo of both working harmoniously together. They do some very heavy lifting to draw (and hold) your eye away from the obvious flaws: centering, snow, honest corners, etc. I love this card and I suspect someone else does too, but if they don’t… you know where to find me šŸ˜‰

garrett
garrett COUNCIL B+ 4/20/2026

Card has some wear and signature isn’t perfect. What I love about this card is the transition era signature before he developed the half moon style. The signature makes the flaws not matter as much to me.

p_baseball_14
p_baseball_14 COUNCIL A- 4/18/2026

The flaws just don't collectively move the needle downward that much. The image and that vintage signature are a bounty for the eye!

littletex_collection
littletex_collection COUNCIL A- 4/2/2026

Great centering and ball-point player era auto, what's more. Beautiful copy.

julytangowhiskey
julytangowhiskey COUNCIL A- 3/30/2026

Amazing early signature that overwhelms the card’s condition issues. Mick knew where to sign even as a youngster. The card itself is far from perfect but the framing is reasonable & the image is clear. Special card regardless of what the flip may say.

mattyc_collection
mattyc_collection COUNCIL B+ 3/7/2026

The eye appeal would soar if that lead M was boldly struck. This is a 1957-57 auto, which is very rare.

arnotcollection
arnotcollection COUNCIL B+ 3/7/2026

Auto looks a little sloppy compared to his cards signed later, but this seems like a more rare and sought after playing days auto. Centering could be a little better and there is corner and surface wear, but it looks good overall.

jlem
jlem COUNCIL C+ 3/4/2026

A bit too much rounding of the corners for my liking. Surface issues in the middle of the card. The "M" in Mickey has light spots. The auto isn't as attractive as others I've seen.

mrreality68
mrreality68 COUNCIL B+ 3/4/2026

Nice looking card and nice clean autograph that is legible would love it a bit bolder(but that is a nit pick) and it is on a card that is really nice looking Add it together and I am drooling

B+
10 reviews
A-
1 review

EyeQ+

153.0
Lord Slabington - Unicorn
Global Population
5
POPULATION ACROSS ALL GRADES AND GRADING COMPANIES
Global Eye Rank
#1
Population in Grade
1
POPULATION IN THIS GRADE ACROSS ALL GRADING COMPANIES
Eye Rank in Grade
#1

EYEQ+ TROPHY CASE

Global Badge Level 1
1st Place
GLOBAL
In-Grade Badge Level 1
1st Place
IN-GRADE
šŸ“Š

Rating Distribution

11 total reviews

G
0%
A+
0%
A
0%
A-
4 ratings
40%
4
B+
5 ratings
50%
5
B
0%
B-
0%
C+
1 rating
10%
1
C
0%
C-
0%
D+
0%
D
0%
D-
0%
F
0%