1910 American Caramel Honus Wagner

I am very close to clicking God Tier right now. I have it as an A+. The centering is great. The blue is free of any problems. OK I am changing to GT because the wear is at the extreme tips of the corners and even the edges are great. My eye is really drawn in by the perfect centering to the blue and the face. The back, whatever, those markings are actually the card's ownership history so how is that a problem for my eye.

Holy @#'n Cow

Smokeshow. That blue background is immaculate. Not a crease or problem in sight. Corners from God Tier.

Beautiful card with "honest corners"

The MK on the back matters to me not. What a clean surface and bright blue. Nice centering and bright white borders. Corners keep it out of GT for me. Stunning example.

On a card like this my eye can be nearly 100% pleased with corner wear of this degree. The MK on back in this case adds history and character. It does not dampen eye appeal at all to me.

Only thing more I could want here would be sharper corners, but the image is so clean and sharp that I would be totally satisfied with this example. Bravo!

Very rarely do you see this card look this nice. Typical wear on the corners, perfect image and surface area, very good centering and an unoffensive stamp on the back.

The Blue really POPS out and the image is really solid. The card has nice framing by the borders. I like the centering and the borders are relatively bright especially for a 115 year old card.

Such a beautiful image and so well-centered. Blue background is virtually flawless. Face is well-focused. Bravo to the owner.