1958 Topps Mickey Mantle #150

Doesn't get much better than this. TPG 3 is laughable.

Amazing copy. Centering, corners, color, registration, edges all amazing!

Ignoring flip, just staring at it as instructed. God Tier. I would be 100% satisfied owning this. Even assuming there is some very subtle wrinkle that only pops out with light hitting it at an angle, this card really proves how out of touch the old system is with the real world of collectors looking at their cards for beauty and enjoyment.

Truly bizarre grade. Card is spectacular.

I stare and stare, waiting to see if something will creep out and bother my eye. But nope. Really, not a thing. I could nitpick and say it maybe sits a hair low, but that would be seeking a flaw to nitpick, and that isn't the same as grading the Eye Appeal. The question is NOT, "Is there a flaw?" The question IS, "Does anything here bother my eye at all?" That's a resounding, "No." Yes, I am a lawyer.

From an Eye Appeal point of view it hits most everything. All that held it back was the top/bottom centering/border size and some minor speckling on the background But an Amazing card and the slab Doctor missed his eye appointment that day

This is a stunner. Beautiful centering and the colors really stand out. I'd be happy to have this as a forever copy. Phenomenal example.

WTF! Looks like we’ve found another example that’ll quickly tell you what this site is all about..

If this isn't God Tier eye appeal, what is? And that is with me imagining it raw as per the rules here. Now that I did that, can we talk about how it looks mint yet was given a 3?

Wow amazing find. Dead centered, color and image look perfect. I zoomed in to try to find a flaw but I don't see any.