1910 E103 Williams Caramel Co. Ty Cobb

Left right centering and the upper right corner distract.

Yes, the corners are beat up and stained, but the image has great color and clarity.

This card has survived oceans of time with its dignity intact. A rather extreme centering shift coupled with one severely damaged corner result in respectable eye appeal that must fall short of the highest tiers. The visual strength of the central image and background are cause for celebration.

Sneaks into B tier for me with the beautiful color and saturatuob particularly in the portrait that really helps to focus the eye - some flaws quickly hold it back from there like the top right corner.

Obvious issues but eye appealing in the sense that you just don’t see this one often in any grade

cool color

Centering and top right corner hold it back for me.

Obviously centering and top right impact eye appeal, yet for me Cobb's portrait being problem free allows me to enjoy the card in a way that keeps the aesthetics in the second tier.

Ty's image being problem-free keeps the eye appeal in the third tier for me, as centering and the top left corner do impact eye appeal.

The colors and image as still bright but to much surface wear, many spots and the extreme centering and border mis-sized holds it back This is not a card a could enjoy for long