Have you tried the COMPARE feature yet? If a card has several in the pop, hit COMPARE and then select 2 or 3 for side-by-side evaluating.

1957 Topps Willie Mays #10

1 / 2
Willie Mays
💬

Reviews & Discussions

8 total reviews

mr_titus_jr
mr_titus_jr COUNCIL A 5/29/2026

Slight snow to the card and the smallest OC. I would be close to that A+ grade other than that.

jbrules
jbrules COUNCIL A 5/28/2026

Borders are bright and the colors are way above average. Stunning card with the centering keeping this from being higher rating along with the touches on the corners.

dchase
dchase COUNCIL GOD TIER 10/4/2025

Perfectly centered with no snow and beautiful white borders. A perfect 57 Topps card.

arnotcollection
arnotcollection COUNCIL A+ 10/3/2025

A slight centering shift keeps this out of god tier for me.

mrreality68
mrreality68 COUNCIL A 10/1/2025

First I see an off center border. But than All I see is a Great Card. Nice size borders and clean(but does not POP from signs of againg) The main image has has detail and strong colors. This is a card to take and enjoy

pjstrina
pjstrina COUNCIL GOD TIER 9/28/2025

The centering is not truly perfect yet the card still gives me that reaction I get when I give a card God Tier eye appeal. The picture focus, clean surface, corners being square, it comes together in a way where I don't notice the centering as much as I normally would.

mattyc_collection
mattyc_collection COUNCIL A+ 9/28/2025

This is one of those cards that at first glance, I think, "Wow, if I saw this at a show, I am after it." Super eye appeal and a little centering shift keeps it from GT. But the overall reaction is: yes, this card has "it."

A
Locked
1 review

EyeQ+

147.0
Lord Slabington - Unicorn
Global Population
6
POPULATION ACROSS ALL GRADES AND GRADING COMPANIES
Global Eye Rank
#1
Population in Grade
2
POPULATION IN THIS GRADE ACROSS ALL GRADING COMPANIES
Eye Rank in Grade
#1

EYEQ+ TROPHY CASE

Global Badge Level 1
1st Place
GLOBAL
In-Grade Badge Level 1
1st Place
IN-GRADE
📊

Rating Distribution

8 total reviews

G
2 ratings
29%
2
A+
2 ratings
29%
2
A
3 ratings
43%
3
A-
0%
B+
0%
B
0%
B-
0%
C+
0%
C
0%
C-
0%
D+
0%
D
0%
D-
0%
F
0%